6 Actions You Can Take to Lower Your Cyber Insurance Premiums

Cyber insurance has become an essential part of a modern risk management strategy. However, over the past few years, premiums have skyrocketed, and underwriting requirements have become significantly more stringent. This isn't just a market correction; it's a direct response to a rapidly evolving threat landscape. For CISOs and other IT leaders, understanding these drivers is the first step toward regaining control and lowering costs.

The primary reason for the surging premiums is the increased frequency and severity of cyberattacks, particularly ransomware. Attackers are becoming more sophisticated, and the financial impact of a single breach—including legal fees, regulatory fines, and business interruption—has reached an all-time high. Insurers, faced with massive payouts that are sometimes exceeding the premiums they collect, have been forced to re-evaluate their risk models. The shift to remote work during the pandemic also introduced new vulnerabilities, as employees accessed sensitive data on personal devices and unsecured networks.

Insurance carriers are no longer simply checking boxes on a questionnaire. They are now demanding proof of robust security controls. To get more favorable rates, you must demonstrate a mature security posture that actively mitigates risk.

By proactively improving your cybersecurity defenses, you not only reduce your risk of a breach but also make your organization a more attractive and insurable client. Here are six concrete actions to take:

1. Implement and Enforce Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA)

This is the single most important control insurers are looking for. MFA is no longer optional; it's a mandatory requirement for most policies. A significant percentage of cyberattacks, especially those involving stolen credentials, can be thwarted by MFA. Make sure you have it deployed and enforced across all privileged accounts, remote access services (like VPNs), and cloud applications.

2. Strengthen Your Incident Response Plan (IRP)

Insurers want to know you're prepared for the worst. A well-documented, regularly tested IRP shows that you can respond to an incident quickly and effectively, minimizing financial and reputational damage. Your plan should clearly define roles and responsibilities, include communication protocols, and be tested through tabletop exercises with key stakeholders. An effective plan can significantly reduce the costs of a breach, which directly impacts your insurance claim.

3. Prioritize Backups and Recovery

Ransomware is the biggest driver of claims. The ability to recover from an attack without paying a ransom is a major factor in premium assessment. Implement a robust backup strategy that includes frequent, verified, and air-gapped backups. This means your backups are physically or logically isolated from the network, so a ransomware attack can't encrypt them. Test your recovery processes regularly to ensure your data is accessible and your business can resume operations quickly.

4. Conduct Security Awareness Training

The human element is often the weakest link in a security chain. Insurers know this, which is why they favor organizations that invest in their employees. Implement a mandatory and ongoing security awareness training program that includes simulated phishing exercises. This helps build a "human firewall" and significantly reduces the risk of successful social engineering attacks.

5. Adopt and Align with a Recognized Cybersecurity Framework

Demonstrate a commitment to a structured security program by adopting a widely recognized framework like NIST, ISO 27001, or CIS Controls. These frameworks provide a roadmap for building and maturing your security posture. By aligning your practices with one, you show underwriters that your security strategy is not ad-hoc but based on industry-vetted best practices. This can lead to more favorable terms and, in some cases, lower premiums.

6. Partner with a Managed Detection and Response (MDR) Provider

In the past, security was about prevention. Today, it's about swift detection and response. Unfortunately, most internal teams don't have the resources to monitor threats 24/7. This is where a Managed Detection and Response (MDR) provider like Secnap comes in.

MDR services provide a dedicated team of cybersecurity experts who proactively hunt for threats, analyze alerts, and respond to incidents in real-time, around the clock. By having a third-party team constantly monitoring your environment, you significantly reduce the "dwell time" of an attacker—the time they spend inside your network before being detected. This not only minimizes the damage of a potential breach but also shows underwriters that you are serious about protecting your organization.

Insurers see an MDR partnership as a clear signal of a mature security posture. It demonstrates that you have:

• 24/7 Vigilance: Your defenses are never offline.
• Expertise on Demand: You have access to specialized threat hunters and incident responders without the cost of a full-time in-house security operations center (SOC).
• Reduced Risk: By stopping attacks before they escalate, you lower the likelihood of a major claim.

Conclusion

Soaring cyber insurance premiums aren't a penalty for your organization; they're a signal to invest in a more robust security posture. By implementing these six controls, you not only fortify your defenses against sophisticated threats but also build a compelling case for lower premiums and better policy terms.

In a world where security risks never sleep, neither should your protections. A partnership with a leading MDR provider like Secnap can be the single most impactful step you take to improve your security and satisfy your insurer's requirements. Contact a Secnap expert today for a personalized security assessment. We'll help you identify key vulnerabilities and build a roadmap to a more secure future.

Contact us today to learn more

‍